THERIP
Toggle Navigation
  • About THERIP
  • Home
  • Is Dialogue Possible?
  • Being a Psychoanalyst
  • From the Couch
  • Articles

Adam Phillips · Against Self-Criticism

  • Email

Podcast by psychoanalyst and writer Adam Phillips

London Review (LRB) View this content on LRB's website

Adam Phillips · Against Self-Criticism Self-criticism can be our most unpleasant – our most sadomasochistic – way of loving ourselves.

Details
Category: General Interest
  • Psychoanalysis
  • Adam Phillips

Jean Laplanche - ON THE PSYCHOANALYSIS OF BABIES

  • Email

On the Psychoanalysis of Babies[1]

Jean Laplanche

 

[Translator’s note: “On the Psychoanalysis of Babies” is Jean Laplanche’s response to a 2007 essay by Bernard Golse, Head of Child Psychiatry at the Hôpital Necker–Enfants Malades and Professor of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry at the Université René Descartes. Golse’s essay, “Y a-t-il une psychanalyse possible des bébés?(“Is There Any Possible Psychoanalysis of Babies?”),[2] contests the charge that a “psychoanalysis of children – and still less of babies – has no claim to a legitimate existence” (354). This charge, he argues, is based on the belief that infants are not from outset situated within the temporality of ‘après-coup’, i.e. what Freud called Nachträglichkeit (see note 3, below). To challenge this view, Golse returns to Freud’s original development of Nachträglichkeit and draws extensively on Laplanche’s resumption of it in his ‘general theory of seduction’. Working through a series of accounts of very early infant experience (e.g. the losses of developmental mourning and the apprehension of intersubjectivity, as well as, still earlier, intrauterine existence) Golse argues that from the metapsychological point of view even the youngest infant cannot be said to be outside the temporality of après-coup: tracing back to an original first trauma will always, he claims, be a “fundamentally asymptotic” endeavour (355). To the extent that the theory of après-coup thus remains valid for the understanding of infants themselves, it is possible to “remain a psychoanalyst” in work with young babies and this work may be considered “authentically psychoanalytic” (360).]

         

 

Bernard Golse and I share a mutual understanding that is solid and amiable (on both sides). I shall not discuss his deliberately provocative title concerning a ‘possible psychoanalysis’ of babies. I simply wonder, and assent to the idea that a psychoanalyst cannot and must not forget for a moment that he is an analyst in the presence of a baby. There is, however, a world of difference between this and ‘psychoanalysing’; for one may just as easily be a psychoanalyst in the presence of an ulcerated patient, a paraplegic or someone dying, without, for all that, having recourse to the psychoanalytic act.

Details
Category: General Interest
  • Jean Laplanche
  • babies

Read more: Jean Laplanche - ON THE PSYCHOANALYSIS OF BABIES

Laplanche, Jean

  • Email

Compiled by John Fletcher and Nicholas Ray, September 2012 

Books (including untranslated volumes)

Laplanche, Jean (1961) Hölderlin and the Question of the Father, trans. Luke Carson, Victoria, Canada: ELS Editions, 2007.

-------(1970) Life and Death in Psychoanalysis, trans. Jeffrey Mehlman, Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1976.

-------(1980) Problématiques I: L’angoisse, Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.

-------(1980) Problématiques II: Castration – Symbolisations, Paris: Presses Universitaires de France. [Extract, “Lecture 20 May, 1975” {Anxiety and Symbolization}, trans. Arthur Goldhammer, in Literary Debate : Texts and Contexts, eds. Dennis Hollier and Jeffrey Mehlman, New York: The New Press, 1999.]

-------(1980) Problématiques III: La sublimation, Paris: Presses Universitaires de France. [Extract, “To Situate Sublimation”, trans. Richard Miller, October, no. 28, Spring, 1984].

-------(1981) The Unconscious and the Id: A Volume of Laplanche’s Problématiques (Problématiques IV), trans. Luke Thurston, London: Rebus Press, 1999.

 

Details
Category: Bibliography
  • Jean Laplanche

Read more: Laplanche, Jean

  1. Forming New Knots: Jean Laplanche 1924-2012
  2. Sexual and Other Addictions
  3. From the Other Side of the Couch
  4. Questioning Identities; Philosophy in Psychoanalytic Practice
  5. On Addiction
  6. 2009 - June 6th Mary Lynne Ellis - Time In Practice

Page 10 of 12

  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12

Latest Modified

  • Lacan’s Seminar XXIII on the Sinthome Raul Moncayo in conversation with Dany Nobus
  • Psychoanalytic Journals
  • Is Dialogue Possible?
  • Milner, Jean-Claude - For the Love of Language
  • Johanssen, Jacob - Psychoanalysis and Digital Culture
  • Forgot Login?
  • Sign up

Back to Top

© 2022 THERIP